AI Fundraising Copy With Soul: Sam Stern on What Donors Feel
Nov 6
Sam Stern says AI has read every appeal letter ever published. What it can't know on its own is why your donors give.
Sam Stern is CEO at MagnifyGood, a communications agency for nonprofits, and he built ConnectionWorks, an AI communications system for teams with nobody assigned to communications. He started out owning and managing a group of radio stations, spent 20 years in brand marketing, then 20 in the nonprofit sector. He works from Sarasota.
Sam's clearest example is what most of us hand the tool: a donor who has given ten years in a row, usually $4,000, and lives on the east side of town. In his words, "those are cold raw data kinds of things. You want to get tapping to the emotional component." His alternative starts with a phone call. Ask four or five donors what about your work speaks to them, how they found you, and what made them give. Record and transcribe the calls, then let AI find the pattern. He builds what you learn into a system with three parts, voice, narrative continuity, and relationship architecture, so it holds when staff move on.
If your drafts are correct and still land flat, start here.
In this episode
- Why AI makes nonprofit writing sound the same, and why donors can feel it
- Sam's three parts: voice, narrative continuity, and relationship architecture
- Why he wants nonprofits to say plainly that they use AI, and how
A few ideas to apply at your nonprofit
- Call four or five donors, ask what connected them, record and transcribe the calls, and ask AI to find the pattern before your next appeal.
- Ask AI to help you define one donor persona: what keeps them up at night, what you do about it, and what they feel.
- Ask AI to act as a brand agency and interview you about your organization, then test what comes out on a social post.
Resources Mentioned
Connect with Sam
- ConnectionWorks: https://connectionworks.ai
- MagnifyGood: https://magnifygood.com
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/nonprofitstrategist
Connect with Sarah
- Follow the podcast on Apple Podcasts: https://podcast.nonprofit411.org
- Nonprofit411: https://nonprofit411.org
- LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/in/nonprofit411
- The Generosity Roadmap for Nonprofits, a free class: https://nonprofit411.org/generosity_map
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction
- 05:56 No donor wakes up planning to give
- 12:01 Why AI drafts all sound the same
- 19:25 Voice, story, and relationship
- 27:57 Ask donors for their stories
- 30:42 Have AI interview you




